But what if he still is? Forgive me for being dumb, but what exactly makes him evil?

Whatever it was, do you think he’s trying to redeem himself in a way? Like, he punishes those who sin, those who are with tarnished hearts, those who committed a crime and deserve punishment in the afterlife. He punishes them, right? What if he’s trying to become what he once was before he did the thing that made him evil?

Lucifer never really did anything HORRIBLe. He just went “wow maybe god is kinda nasty maaaang” and god was just ” you dare question my authority? FFFUUUCK YOUUU”.

Then again there’s saint Valhal or smth like that who raped and killed women, men, doges, everything.

Then he was “gode i’m sorry i am truly sorry”
"ok I believe you now since you’re so sorry i’ll make you a saint"

i shit you not

I fucking hate christianity